Free Shipping on orders over $129*


Your Cart is Empty

  • Live Shows
  • pop shop live shows


  • NTWRK shows


  • Toy Shop Live


  • Whatnot shows


  • YouTube


  • Add description, images, menus and links to your mega menu

  • A column with no settings can be used as a spacer

  • Link to your collections, sales and even external links

  • Add up to five columns

  • Some brands we partner with

    Mystery Toy Box Classic

    Select A Plan Below

    12 Month Plan

    12 Month Prepay

    $35.99 per month

    + shipping


    6 Month Plan

    6 Month Prepay

    $36.99 per month

    + shipping


    3 Month Plan

    3 Month Prepay

    $37.99 per month

    + shipping


    Month to Month Plan

    Start here and cancel anytime.

    $39.99 per month
    + shipping


    One Time Box

    Don't want to subscribe? Just wanna try it out? Select a one time box and we'll send it out along the same schedule with our subscriptions



    Mystery Toy Box FAQ

    Managing your subscription

    It is self service. Please login to your account and press cancel.

    Remember to cancel before the 1st of every month before it recurs.

    You do not need to contact us to cancel your subscription.

    Our system will bill you on the 1st of every month.

    If you subscribe to our Month to Month plan, and you happened to subscribe on the 4th of the month, then we would bill you the next month on the 1st 

    If you subscribe to our 3 Month plan, and you happened to subscribe on the 4th, then we would bill you once for 3 Months immediately then in 3 months when the subscription has ended, we would also bill you on the 1st

    It's important to note that all plans recur automatically on their own until you decide to cancel.

    Login to your account and click the manage subscriptions button on the account page.

    Product Information

    Each month, our team along with our partners curates the Mystery Toy Box and each month is a surprise. In general we try to pack at least 5-6 items in each box. We pack a variety of premium quality toys from various brands.

    We do not plan the box around gender. This box is for toy fans that want to explore all kinds of toys and brands. If you are looking for a product that is geared towards a specific gender, this box is not right for you.

    Not at this time. This will change soon as we are exploring different subscription payment methods that can allow for a mix.

    Yes. But only if you order directly from or We cannot offer points for subscriptions made on the cratejoy platform.


    We offer a flat fee shipping rate of $9.99 USD for shipping within the lower 48 US states. Shipping is calculated during checkout for other countries.

    For the classic box, we typically fullfill and send all orders out on or around the 15th of every month. If you order before the 15th of every month, we will include your order into the next shipment. If you subscribe from the 15-31st of the month, your next box will ship the next following month.  

    In the USA, shipping is provided by either USPS or UPS. In Canada, the shipping service is provided by Canada Post or local courier if located in the GTA. For international orders outside the US and Canada, we will use POSTNL and/or APC Logisitics.

    In the USA, you should expect your Mystery Toy Box to arrive anywhere from 3-6 days.

    In Canada, please expect your Mystery Toy Box to arrive anywhere from 2-7 days depending on your location.

    For International customers, it can take anywhere from 14-45 days for international shipments.

    We're looking into it but not at the moment. It is only available as a subscription online.